August 04, 2006
Possession
Earlier, I mentioned being struck by A.S. Byatt's Possession, after having read about a third of it in a single evening. Unfortunately, as I approach the halfway mark, my attention is wandering and I find myself unable to read more than a chapter without having to put it down.
The premise seemed intriguing at first: a rumpled scholar named Roland, who specializes in the life and works of a long-dead poet, discovers some affectionate notes written by him to a mysterious poetess. Roland subsequently meets up with a female scholar (whose specialty is of course the poetess in question) and together they discover that the two poets enjoyed a sort of intellectual infatuation/affair through a series of letters. Alongside this mystery is an amusing satire of the literary-academic world, and an emerging relationship between the two modern scholars as they attempt to uncover this secret romance.
Unfortunately, I don't really like poetry and the book is full of verses written by the poets, Randolph Ash and Christabel LaMotte. I tried to read every line carefully, but eventually I gave up and started skimming. The excerpts were obviously hinting at various things, but I find reading poetry to be a largely painful experience. Blame my short attention span and general lack of interest in literary frippery.
The letters between Randolph and Christabel were initially interesting because they appeared so cordial, but had a subtle undercurrent of affection. However, the extended poetry discussion and intellectual wanking about Victorian "pop culture" topics (seances, microscopes, etc) made the letters slow and irritating to read as well.
I feel I should be more moved by this, but the story seems so overwrought and slow. Perhaps if I return to it later...
Has anyone else read Posession? I'm desperately hoping the women-only book club that conscripted me months ago doesn't discover this one.
Posted by eerie at August 4, 2006 09:44 PM
Filed Under:
Reviews
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.aqoul.com/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/2867
Comments
Well, apart from one of the poems (the one about the seance), the poetry is more a way of exploring the characters than explicating plot. But if you're getting bored with the letters (the high point of the book, as far as I'm concerned, apart from the fairy-tales), you're probably just as well off walking away.
Posted by: Tom Scudder at August 5, 2006 02:58 AM
Regardless of what they explore, the poetry still bores me. It's...bloody poetry.
The letters are definitely more readable, but overall this book requires some persistence. I'm still reading because there are a few small hooks I want to follow, but the whole thing seems overwrought and...in love with itself.
I must confess that the male poet is not convincing to me as a character. I just dont believe that a man would behave as he does (except in the fantasies of a woman, i.e. the author).
Posted by: eerie
at August 5, 2006 05:34 AM
There is a scene later in the book that makes the male character's behavior a lot more explicable. But, like I said, I LIKE poetry, so I'm probably not a good guide as to whether this is a book worth reading for you.
Posted by: Tom Scudder at August 5, 2006 09:42 AM
There is only one poem I like, by some French guy whose name escapes me.
Otherwise I find it a bit boring. One thing that does amuse me is the "commentary" on academics inferring personality by studying letters and works, and how easy it is to get things totally wrong by imposing one's own biases on the person being studied.
Imagine if, in the future, people tried to figure us out by reading our blogs. Hah.
Posted by: eerie
at August 5, 2006 11:22 AM
Tom Stoppard's Arcadia is awesome on the same subject - you see events happening in the 19th century, and then historians trying to piece together what happened in the 20th, and of course they get it all wrong. Great play.
(Mind you, I went to see it because a woman I had a crush on was working backstage, but it's still a great play).
Posted by: Tom Scudder at August 5, 2006 11:46 AM

RSS



